Carter King at Midtown High School
2023
—
Atlanta,
GA/US
Varsity Public Forum Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Nur Awad
Midtown High School
None
Matt Bartula
Sequoyah High School
Last changed on
Thu January 4, 2024 at 10:37 AM EDT
I strongly believe in narrowing the debate in the summary speeches. I really want you to determine where you are winning the debate and explain that firmly to me. In short: I want you to go for something. I really like big impacts, but its's important to me that you flush out your impacts with strong internal links. Don't just tell me A leads to C without giving me the process of how you got there. Also don't assume i know every minute detail in your case. Explain and extend and make sure that you EMPHASIZE what you really want me to hear. Slow down and be clear. Give me voters (in summary and final focus).
Speed is fine as long as you are clear. I work very hard to flow the debate in as much detail as possible. However, if I can't understand you I can't flow you.
John Cowan
Midtown High School
Last changed on
Mon January 9, 2023 at 9:01 AM EDT
- I'm a former assistant coach to a Speech and Debate team in another state. (2016-2019)
- My preference for speed is roughly a 7 -- If a one is the sloth from Zootopia and 10 is policy debater. If I can't understand you and can't flow your arguments then I can't consider them in judging.
- In the final speeches for each team I like to hear voting issues. Tell me why your side wins and where it wins.
- Please clearly announce the start and end of your prep time, as it is courteous to your opponents and judges.
- I don't flow Cross, so if you find an opening in cross you need to bring it up in your next speech where I will flow it.
- More than anything else though, please give me some impacts to your arguments, and weigh your impacts versus your opponents'.
Kate Ippen
Midtown High School
None
John Moye
Midtown High School
None
Jack Rafferty
Midtown High School
None
Sudha Reddy
Midtown High School
None
Norm Richie
Midtown High School
Last changed on
Thu January 5, 2023 at 5:43 AM EDT
I am a parent judge - 2020-2021 was my twins' final year as high school debaters, and I usually judged at almost every tournament, so I have been lucky enough to see a bunch of really great rounds. I typically judged PF, but have also judged a fair amount of LD.
I am looking for a DEBATE - not just the best speeches. I will give the win to the team that makes the most compelling case as to why their side is right and/or the opponent is wrong. I tend not to flow every specific point, but rely more on which team's overall argument is stronger. I probably put more weight on cross-ex and final summary arguments than most judges.
I usually am more convinced by a smaller number of really great points that are well defended than a whole bunch of pretty good points (quality of argument versus quantity). I am also looking for the debaters to pay attention to what their opponent says and specifically give a good counter argument to those points.
Last changed on
Mon March 25, 2024 at 5:19 AM EDT
Im Will Roberson this is my third year judging/competing in PF
- let me know if you drop anything
- No new evidence in second summary
- have evidence prepared
- im ok with normal vernacular
- pls extend all evidence I firmly believe this is critical to keep a link chain intact
- pls be respectful in all cross i don't mind if you tell during speeches though
- im okay with spreading just don't go crazy with it
- Tech>truth