Red Devil Rhetoric
2020
—
Jackson,
GA/US
Novice Lincoln Douglas Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Terence Fitzgerald
Starrs Mill High School
Last changed on
Tue September 17, 2024 at 9:39 AM EDT
I've been the Speech & Debate Coach at Starr's Mill H.S since 2018. My team only competes in Public Forum and Speech events, so that is where I have the most experience coaching and subsequently judging.
PF:
- I'm not a tech judge. Make quality, consistent, logical arguments with clearly stated, explained, relevant evidence and you won't have a problem winning the round.
- Do not spread. Do not ask if I or your competitors want your case as a workaround.
- For high speaker points, I look for sportsmanship, politeness, clear rhetoric, consistent signposting (i.e. referring to the argument you are responding to as you go down the flow), and timeliness.
- I am not a judge for off-the-wall stuff (topicality, kritiks, etc.).
- I do not flow cross, but I have decided rounds on crucial admissions and will take notes "on the side" as need be.
LD:
- I am a lay judge. I only judge PF or Speech so if I get placed in a LD round, it's usually a one-off.
- Do not spread. Do not ask if I or your competitors want your case as a workaround.
- I'm not receptive to most counterplans and prefer standard LD cases.
- Value/Value Criterion will absolutely weigh in my decision.
Joey Jowers
Valdosta High School
None
Marcie Kinney
Cherokee HS
None