Last changed on
Thu October 21, 2021 at 10:38 AM EDT
General
Respect your judges and competitors.
Follow the rules, as I read them and will ask Tab staff if there are any issues.
Be timely to your round.
Debate
I judge mostly on the content you provide and how you approach your opponent's speeches. However, your delivery is important in order for me to hear and understand you. I do flow the debates and will use my flow to do a majority of my own deliberation. Please use signposts, it will make it far easier for me to focus on your content, rather than where you are in your speech. I will prioritize certain points if you provide evidence or backing as to why they should be prioritized.
DO NOT SPREAD! I will not be able to keep up, it will not be an instant loss, but your points are far more likely to slip off (or not even appear) on my flow.
If you are to use theory, rather than evidence, please make sure you have adequate support as to why I should care (it’s the same for the vice versa). You may discuss general points, but show me impact. No non-topical kritiks.
For LD, your CV and VC are incredibly important as to why you win. However, you can win through other means if the values and criteria are a wash.
Online: Normally I would use a check and x system on my ballots. But due to online functionality, I will use :) and :( .
Congress
I judge your score based on a combination of how well it is written, the content of the speech, the delivery of the speech, and how it applies based on what has happened thus far in the chamber. I will rank you based on your scores, your questioning, and what your impact was on the chamber.
I want to see rebuttals and new content.
I do not want to see repetitious points or speeches with all words, no content.
I want questions that influence the flow of debate.
I don’t want gotcha questions that are only for making your opponent look bad (If it otherwise influences debate it is okay, but don’t do it maliciously).
Some level of purposeful blocking and vocal inflections during your speech would be recommended.
Speech
I will judge you based on a combination of vocality, movement, and content (these will weigh differently based on your respective event [this is not to say the ones weighed lower are unimportant]).
Please stand out in your event, it will make you more memorable when I am ranking you. Do not be monotone or use minimal blocking. Appropriate vocal pacing and emphasis are key to making it high on my ballot.
Please be respectful of other speakers, when they are presenting. Please stay attentive (or at least act like it). I know many of you will see the same script up to 4 times a day, but remember you want your judge and audience to give you attention, so do the same for them.
Your event has recommended guidelines for the judge, but they are also for you. Make sure you excel in each of them and you are more likely to rank higher. If you are unable to locate this, please read your league’s website or ask your coach, not your judge.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Good luck and have fun! :-D