PHSSL District 9 Tournament
2021
—
NSDA Campus,
PA/US
Debate Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Brittany Bunting-Specht
Selinsgrove Area High School
None
Aidan Finnerty
Selinsgrove Area High School
None
Victoria Fischer
Danville Area High School
Last changed on
Mon January 8, 2024 at 7:54 AM EDT
I like to see content backed by sources, as well as clean debate. Do not personally attack your opponent, and I do not like spreading - nor will I vote for your side if I can't understand a word you're saying. Vocal intonation, vocal modulation, dynamic voice, appropriate pacing and pausing, clear enunciation, eye contact, facial expressions, and gestures are all tools that can support your presentation. Spreading and gish galloping in my opinion are NOT tools. Be honest and respectful in your presentation. Focus on framework and the value. Not one to disclose.
Richard Ludwig
Danville Area High School
Last changed on
Thu January 18, 2024 at 8:56 AM EDT
My strength is in speech and I have years of both coaching and judging students in every speech event. I also have several years coaching and judging debate as well. When presenting (regardless of what event you are in) you have multiple tools available to use to enhance, PERSUADE and connect with your audience. Vocal intonation, vocal modulation, dynamic voice, appropriate pacing and pausing, CLEAR ENUNCIATION, eye contact, facial expressions, and gestures are all tools that can support your presentation. Whether you're presenting an interpretation, an oratory, or a position in a debate use those tools. While debating, present your argument, your facts, your position and connect it all to persuade me you're correct. Spreading and gish galloping in my opinion are NOT tools and if you choose those tactics I will not be happy and your rank will reflect that mis-step. Also DO NOT waste your time telling me why I should be voting for you when you should be persuading me. In Congressional Debate be strategic in asking questions to better position your argument. Additionally, always move the debate forward. Be HONEST and RESPECTFUL in your presentation.
Last changed on
Tue January 9, 2024 at 11:06 AM EDT
I prefer speakers with a steady pace and whose case has a strong organization supported by appropriately cited evidence. If the pace is rapid, I will quit listening and lean strongly toward the opposing side. I expect speakers to be professional in their presentations and to treat their opponents with dignity and respect.