Norma J Smith Memorial Tournament Poteau
2022
—
Poteau,
OK/US
CX Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Victoria Fisher
Poteau High School
None
Chris Larcade
Muldrow High School
Last changed on
Thu January 4, 2024 at 3:39 AM CDT
Email : chris.larcade@staff.muldrowps.org
BASIC NEED TO KNOW:
Spreading: Need taglines to be clear. If I can't flow it, I can't use it to vote for you
Argumentation | Rhetoric: I look for debate speaking. I love to see debate falsies being used to disprove arguments.
Topicality: I will vote on it if I feel the NEG proved it to be abusive.
K Arguments- I will vote on "K" if you break it down to an understandable level. The LINK must be clear and offset the impacts of the AFF.
Inherency: If the NEG proves it is already being done, I will vote on it
Things I DON'T like
- Framework: I am not a fan of heavy framework arguments. Your impact should provide the voters for me to make my decision.
- Abuse Arguments: I have heard a lot of these arguments this season. I can determine what is and is not abuse for myself throughout a round. If your entire case is based on abuse, it appears that your case is not solid on its own merit.
- Ignoring your opponent's argument just to extend your own arguments and hope that their argument goes away.
Things I DO like
- Confidence: Don't give me a reason to vote you down. If you show me that you lost an argument with your non-verbals, then you will lose the argument.
- CLASH: I love it! Especially in cross-examination.
- TAGLINES: Once again, if I can't flow it then I will not vote for it.
- Sportsmanship: Don't make personal attacks, be professional and HAVE FUN.
Samantha Phillips
Keys High School
None
Skyler Phillips
Bixby High School
Last changed on
Thu November 26, 2020 at 6:27 AM EDT
Tabula Rasa
Zak Rajpari
Keys High School
Last changed on
Fri February 4, 2022 at 11:45 AM CDT
Debated CX and LD in high school, 2006-2010. Debated Parli 2011-2015. Had some success in both spheres. Am a bit rusty with higher levels of debate but can probably keep up in most rounds.
I'm a lazy judge and want to vote on the easiest way to pull the trigger at the end of the round. The best way to get there is with obvious offense and impact calc/cost benefit/some sort of weighing at the end of the round.
I'm open to any kinds of arguments including K and procedurals.
I do my best to judge based on what happened on the flow, but that is with the expectation that arguments have substance.
Please differentiate between cards and tags! Use AND or NEXT or something like that.