Be Herd 2023
2023 — HEREFORD, TX/US
LD/PF Paradigm List
All Paradigms: Show HideCongress
I appreciate competitors who are knowledgeable enough to speak extemporaneously while addressing information and speakers that have already participated. Students should participate actively in the chamber's motions and show leadership even when not presiding. Questions should lead to potential arguments.
LD
I tend to be fairly progressive and will listen to any arguments you run. I am fine with condo and collapsing. Winning framing is important and will influence my decision in the round BUT will not be a skate to a ballot. I don't mind LARPING or any other strat you may make use of, provided you do it well and convince me of your positions. I am fine with speed and will want to be on the email chain. I prefer philosophical debates but don't mind whatever you want to throw at me.
Policy - see above
I am a tab judge and am open to hearing your positions. I will not advocate on the flow. I am open to collapse strats and prefer non-generic arguments that have a real link. I wish we would stop arguing end of world impacts but will vote on them
I competed in Policy Debate in high school (grad. 2012) and competed at UIL State. I have been involved with Speech and Debate in varying capacities since then and have coached since 2022.
I value strategy, clash, and believe Policy Debate at its core is still a speaking event.
I would consider myself a “stock issues plus” judge. The stock issues matter to me in debate, but I have grown more interested in progressive styles of debate and will flow these arguments as long as you do the theory work and explain your arguments well. I will not connect any dots for you.
I don’t mind speed as long as you maintain clarity. If I feel you are unclear, I will stop flowing.
I don’t love voting on Topicality because, for most of my career, it has been used largely as a timesuck argument. However, this year, topicality is incredibly relevant. Carry your argument all the way through to get my vote on T.
I prefer highly technical DAs and will be looking for all of the ingredients. One of my most important voting issues will be impact calc!
If you run a CP, tell me why I should prefer your plan. I’m looking for Net Benefits/Mutual Exclusivity for you to win. Spell out how you solve better.
At the end of the day, my decision will be largely based on world comparison and impact calc. Tell me why you should win! Good luck!