Last changed on
Fri January 26, 2024 at 12:29 PM CDT
Hello!
My name is Nikhil Pochana. I'm a junior at LAMP High School. I've done speech and debate for almost 2 years. I've competed regularly in different events across the speech and debate spectrum, including LD.
My email is npochana0417@gmail.com if you want to share your speech docs with me.
Ria Shah Novice Tournament:
This is a novice tournament. As such, I automatically prefer traditional rounds. This means focus on framework and the substantive arguments of the round. I don't really want to see any complex progressive or policy args; please be mindful of the purpose of the tournament and of the experience levels of your opponent. Above anything, the round should serve as a learning opportunity for everyone. Do your part to keep it that way.
A few things to note:
1) Please watch your speed. Personally, I'm fine with spreading as long as I have a speech doc. But you're competing in a novice tournament, so remember that. Speak at a normally understandable pace.
2) I like framework. I don't care if that makes me weird. I like it. So debate it. Explain why I should vote on your fw and why I shouldn't vote on your opponent's. Make sure that you tie your impacts to the fw as you weigh.
3) Weighing is particularly important in traditional rounds--it's how I determine who won the round. Please weigh!!!!!!!!!!!
4) The 2nd half of the round (end of 1ar forward) is where the round is won. Use it wisely. Start focusing on key points of clash and explain why I should vote your side on that issue over your opponent.
5) Use your final speech to give voters. The 2nr/2ar should be a prewritten RFD--it needs to explicitly explain why you won.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Prefs:
tech > truth
Extend it if you want me to evaluate it
Please do not assume that I know everything about the topic--explain and flush out your arguments.
I do not flow cx, so extend whatever was said in your speeches if you want me to flow it
Give an off-time roadmap and ask if everyone is ready before beginning your speech.
Signpost. If I don't understand it, I can't flow it. So tell me where you are in your speech (Ex.: On contention 1, they said....)
Just b/c the arg is conceded doesn't necessarily mean I'll vote on it/it'll give you offense. You need to explain the implications the concession has on your position--explain why it benefits you and what it means for the round.
Above all, be respectful of everyone in the round. No homophobia, sexism, racism, etc., or personal criticism of your opponent--that will be an automatic drop.
Speaks will be given based on speaking quality (tone, intonation, clarity) and your overall presence in the round.
Remember, this tournament is a learning experience for everyone. Do your best and have fun!