CBSR Team Debates and Congress 3
2024
—
Redlands,
CA/US
Debate Paradigm List
All Paradigms:
Show
Hide
Jonathan Brandenburg
Los Osos High School
None
Kyle Brodie
Claremont
None
Selina Chang
Claremont
None
Margaret Daniels
Yucaipa High School
None
Amy Depew
Santiago High School
Last changed on
Sat April 13, 2024 at 2:18 AM PDT
Hello debaters! I am your friendly, neighborhood judge here to give you a few tips about me. I am a parent volunteer and I have been judging for about two years. I look for solid logical arguments and the ability to refute poor logic. You've worked hard to be here so please make sure I can understand you. Don't speak so quickly that your words disappear. Don't be too quiet, but please don't shout at me either. One last note, please DO NOT talk over each other. Be respectful of each other.
Amy
James Duncan
Santiago High School
None
Autumn Earle-Rodriguez
Redlands High School
None
Camilla Flowers
Citrus Valley High School
None
Diana Garibay
Redlands High School
None
Salvador Garibay
Redlands High School
None
BrittMary Guerre-Aguilar
Redlands High School
None
Mario Hernandez-Margarito
Cajon High School
None
Klemens Huynh
Redlands High School
None
Katherine Irvine
Claremont
Last changed on
Fri April 12, 2024 at 6:21 AM PDT
I am a volunteer parent with over a year’s experience judging speech and debate events. I judge for a number of reasons, most importantly is that a seeing the skills and dedication students have for connecting community members and making society batter for all GIVES ME JOY AND HOPE!
In order for me to best judge events it helps me if students:
- Speak slowly enough for people who may be unfamiliar with the subject vocabulary to follow what they are saying;
- Project their voices and speak more loudly if they notice me leaning or cupping an ear toward them;
- Are silent, still audience members; and,
- Keep noise to a minimum in buildings where events are taking place.
In debates, as I do my best to follow the arguments, logic, supporting points, refutations, and how definitions and weighing mechanisms apply. When students explicitly indicate what points they are providing support or a critique for, and how they think their definitions and weighing mechanisms matter, it helps me be a better judge of these important factor.
Also, I recognize that critiquing and interrupting others, speaking loudly, dramatic gesturing, and heckling are all used in various debates, but I also pay close attention to any instances of people invading the personal space of others, yelling at or personally insulting their opponent, or otherwise not respecting the equal rights of all debaters, and I will ask coaches for guidance in how to judge what I think I have seen. I love the community I see among speech and debate teams!
I hope EVERY student feels proud and enjoys tournaments as I am impressed by the work and courage of EVERYONE participating. If students do not get the recognition they hoped for I encourage them to remember that judges such as me are not professionals and may make mistakes. That may be a reality we all have to accept, but if anything seems unfair please speak with a coach.
Best wishes and thank you for your consideration.
Last changed on
Fri January 12, 2024 at 10:39 PM PDT
Hello! My name is Cheng Han Li, and I’m a former MSPDP and CHSSA debater. I specialized in Original Advocacy and Public Forum Debate.
In a round, as a flow judge, I look for things such as impact calculus, clash, signposting, and roadmapping. What I look for in rounds depends on the trichotomy, but one thing I always want is facts and logic, preferably backed up with evidence. I don’t like it when debaters don’t use up their full time, but I don’t like spreading either, so find the middle ground. I will stop writing things down after 15 seconds over time, and will verbally stop you after 30 seconds over time. POIs are encouraged.
I only give out bad scores to debaters who are disrespectful to others or to debaters who stray entirely off-topic.
I will give the win to the team who presents their case the best, or the team that best supports their trichotomy.
Please talk to the JUDGE (aka me). After all, you aren't going to convince your opponent.
P.S. Good luck :)
karl marcellini
Redlands High School
None
April Martinez
Claremont
None
Johannes Moenius
Redlands High School
Last changed on
Fri March 1, 2024 at 11:51 PM PDT
First and foremost, I would like to let you know how much I respect all the effort you have been spending for preparing for your tournaments. I am looking forward to seeing a glimpse of how you will bring it to fruition.
I am a lay judge. I value information rich, logically consistent arguments. I also appreciate skillful rhetoric.
I will try to flow, but if contentions are dropped, make sure you make that clear and emphasize impacts of these concessions.
Mickayla Narez
Claremont
None
Victoria Nitch
Redlands High School
None
Alanna Quinn
Los Osos High School
Last changed on
Sat January 13, 2024 at 12:34 AM PDT
Hello! :D
I did speech and debate my entire time in high school, with a focus on IE and Congress. I've watched a lot of debate rounds over the years, but please treat me like I know absolutely nothing! I like to see well-outlined cases with clear evidence, values, contentions, transitions, etc. I take a lot of notes, and I always refer back to them when I make my decision.
There will always be clashing evidence and, instead of arguing the same point back and forth, please focus on the value/value criterion! It's my favorite part of debate, so state and connect them clearly throughout your entire case. If you feel like you're mentioning it too much, that's just the way I like it :).
Also, it's never impacted my decision, but presentation is important to me! I was a speech kid, after all. Enunciate, have good volume, good posture, etc. Whatever makes you look and feel confident at the podium.
Adam Ramirez
Los Osos High School
Last changed on
Sun April 14, 2024 at 2:47 AM PDT
I used to do debate. Economics and Education are my specialties.
I am not a lay judge. If you see me stop typing then go onto your next point
I will consider goofy arguments if they are better than serious ones. As long as they are debated correctly.
IMPACTS IMPACTS IMPACTS
PLEASE don't knock on the desk after each speech.
If you want feedback ask me after the round. I will not be writing long RFD’s.
If both teams agree I will judge a round off of double loss theory.
Do NOT spread. I will stop listening and start playing Clash of Clans.
Do NOT BS your information. I will know...
But if you can make it rhyme your score will be prime.
If you have a P.O.O. please say “Pause time Poop” That will be funny I think.
good luck.
Last changed on
Fri February 9, 2024 at 10:58 AM PDT
I'm a traditional judge who prefers non circuit arguments. Evidence is important, but you should also use logic and reasoning to persuade me. Spreading is a no go with me, if you start I'll tune you out.
Rich Spencer
Redlands High School
None
Shuping Wang
Redlands High School
None
Melinda Warren
Claremont
None
Owais Zaidi
Claremont
None
Cheryl Zhang
Claremont
None
Lisa Zhang
Santiago High School
None
XINGDONG ZHANG
Redlands High School
None
Sarah Zhong
Redlands High School
None