Brandeis Bronco Bash TFA NIETOC
2021 — Online, TX/US
Speech Paradigm List
All Paradigms: Show HideJudge Name: Laurence Howard
sechs.laurencehoward@gmail.com
No School Affiliation
Years Judging: 5
Specialty: LD
Specific Paradigm(s): Games Player & Speaking skills/communications
Importance of (Scale of 1-10):
- Evidence (Inclusion of "hard" empirical evidence): 8
- Analysis (Logical claims explain the inherent problems): 8
- Clash (Refutation of opposing positions): 10
- Questions (Answers to questions clarify with precision): 9
- Delivery (Speaks smoothly, clearly, controlled, and polished): 10
Other comments: For me, the most important things are the ability to follow the logic of your arguments and refutation of opposing points -- why are your points important? why do they outweigh the arguments from the opposing side? Delivery and speed are super important to me as well; I'm glad you are providing evidence to help your position, but if I, and even your opponent, are unable to follow you because of speed or the constant use of the word "like" that becomes a problem.
For Interp Events: I like to see relatable pieces. I enjoy seeing how your passion comes through as your give your speech. I also appreciate preparation; along with a topic that is close to you, I want to see that you have sufficiently practiced and are ready to give your speech. (besides impromptu and improv of course)
When judging speech events, I expect presenters to know their topic well and to present in a clear manner that conveys their knowledge/interest in the topic.
Questions I ask myself while judging include: Does the speaker enjoy what he/she is doing? Does the speaker truly understand, have a vested interest in, or care about the topic/presentation? Does the speaker move or is he/she a statue - frozen in place? Does the speaker change his/her voice accordingly, based on the type of presentation, or is it monotone? Does the speaker utilize the binder in any way, other than to hold it and read from it? Is the speaker adept at utilizing visual aides when available? What does the speaker do to engage the audience and keep their attention?
I enjoy watching your performances and seeing the thinking, creativity, and time speakers invest.
Debate events: I am a traditional judge and want to hear your case and evidence for support. Speak at a rate where you are understood. When you race through a script, and it is difficult to hear/understand what you say, you lose me.
With that in mind, I thank you for allowing me to judge.
This is my fourth year as a parent judge(speech mainly). I have judged in some national speech and debate events: NSDA national, TOC, NIETOC, etc. I emphasize on clarity and confidence in delivery. Do not spread. I need to understand you to rank you high.